Brown County Real Estate | Brown County Homes for Sale | Best Realtor in Nashville, IN | Nineveh | Columbus | Morgantown | Martinsville

Enjoy the Charm of Brown County Living! Discover the possibilities at 5523 Three Notch Road in Nashville, where the opportunity to enjoy a quieter pace of life awaits. Nestled in beautiful Brown County, this property offers a chance to make a place your own while enjoying the area's natural beauty and small-town charm. Whether you are searching for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a property with potential to personalize and make your own, this home offers an opportunity worth exploring. Enjoy the appeal of country living while remaining within reach of Nashville's local shops, restaurants, art galleries, and unique attractions. Brown County is well known for its scenic surroundings, outdoor recreation, and welcoming community, making it an appealing destination for those who appreciate nature and a more relaxed lifestyle. With room to bring your ideas and create a space that fits your needs, this property presents an opportunity for buyers looking to establish their own vision in a desirable Brown County location.

5523 Three Notch Road, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Adrian White. JF Property Group

$649,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 93 Pine Lake Circle in the sought-after Pine Tree Hills neighborhood, just 4 minutes from downtown Nashville. This home sits on a double corner lot that gives you plenty of privacy while still keeping you surrounded by the trees and hills Brown County is known for. Nearly new construction with luxury finishes throughout, it offers 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, with the primary suite and everything you need for daily living on the main floor. The fourth bedroom is currently set up as an office, giving you room to use it however your life needs. Storage is abundant throughout the entire home, with generously sized closets in every bedroom. The chef's kitchen features an oversized island, double ovens with one convection, and a large pantry, making it an entertainer's delight whether you're hosting a holiday dinner or a casual night with friends. The walkout basement adds two spacious bedrooms, a full bath, a second living room, and a bar, so there's room for everyone to spread out. Outdoor space is everywhere you turn. Start your morning on the front porch, unwind in the screened-in porch with quiet Brown County views, enjoy fall evenings by the gas outdoor fireplace, soak in the included hot tub on its own porch, or gather around the wood-burning fire pit. Picture slow mornings watching the hummingbirds and weekends spent on what you actually want to do, because the HOA mows the lawn, maintains the lot, and handles leaf removal, snow removal, and trash. All the chores are taken care of, and town is just minutes away when you want it.

93 Pine Lake Circle, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Jamie Johann. Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Brown County Ranch on 3.41 Acres! Bring your vision and create your own country retreat! This spacious 3 bed 2 bath, 1,952-square-foot home offers a freshly painted kitchen with plenty of cabinet space, new luxury vinyl plank floor, and a formal dining room. Enjoy cozying up by the Bedford stone wood-burning fireplace in the spacious Great Room with new LVP, and newly painted walls as well. The primary bedroom ensuite features a walk-in shower, and walk-in closet,(needs just a few cosmetic touches), and a bonus room for office, exercise, nursery, or other use you may desire. Home features a separate laundry room, new HVAC in 2021, & new roof in 2019, and large insulated detached 2 car garage with attached leanto carport! Outside, relax in a peaceful setting by the firepit and lean-to area, perfect for entertaining, or play in the creek that runs through the woods. There's plenty of open space too for gardening, raising chickens, or bringing your own ideas to life! No HOA. Conveniently located minutes from desirable downtown Nashville and Brown County State Park. This property includes 2 separate lots offering country living with easy access to amenities, local attractions and more. Come explore the possibilities!

6450 State Road 135 N, Morgantown

Listing courtesy of Janet Haight. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

$550,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Situated on a private 14.5 acre lot, with wooded trails, massive garden, fruit trees, a stocked pond and large detached workshop, you'll find this hidden gem of an A-frame in the hills of Brown County! Properties like this one aren't listed often, in fact, this one has been "off market" for nearly 30 years! This home is full of character with woodwork throughout, some of which was actually harvested from the property! Inside, you'll find a living room kitchen, bathroom, laundry room on the main level. At the back of the home, the seller used a large mechanical room as a dry food storage area / storm shelter. On floor two, you'll find two bedrooms, a nice secondary living space and open porch, plus another bathroom. At the very top floor, one more bedroom with a view of it all. The workshop has its own furnace, and newer garage doors on each end with concrete floors for all your storage or project needs. This home is one worth seeing, and has been well loved over the years. Come see your next potential Brown County Home!

9681 N Short Chute, Morgantown

Listing courtesy of Jeremy Tredway. eXp Realty, LLC

$399,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

One-of-a-kind Brown County property on 6.11 acres! Originally a bank building relocated from Helmsburg, this completely remodeled 2-bedroom, 1-bath home still features the original working bank safe in the primary bedroom. The stylish updated kitchen offers stainless steel appliances and hardwood floors flowing into the dining area and sunroom, where you can enjoy beautiful views of the Brown County terrain and access the rear deck. Additional features include cedar-lined closets, heated bathroom floor, electric built-in fireplace, new windows, open front porch, Generac whole-house generator, and a new roof with transferable lifetime warranty. Outside you'll find a heated garage with separate electric meter, porch and deck, firepit area, guest cottage, and a three-bay carport with extended-height RV parking and electrical hookup. An open field with a separate drive is perfect for gatherings, recreation, or extra parking. Located on private Amy Lane with hiking access at the end of the lane leading toward Yellowwood State Forest. Much of the furnishings and yard-care equipment will remain-see list in showing packet.

2459 Amy Lane, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Penny Scroggins. Bear Real Estate Sales, LLC

$789,000

3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths

Experience refined living in a private woodland setting on 6.28 acres at 5941 S. Poplar Grove Rd., Columbus, IN 47201, where attention to detail and unique choices create this one-of-a-kind home located in scenic Brown County Indiana, approximately 20 minutes from Nashville and I-65. Originally constructed in 1967, the residence has been so thoroughly transformed that it functions as a new custom home while keeping its rich original character. The entire first and second floors have been rebuilt, including every major system. New roof, septic system, HVAC, plumbing, windows, doors, appliances, water heaters, etc., and fiber optic internet available, give the assurance that comes with a house that has been comprehensively built for modern living. Approximately 3,500 square feet of thoughtfully designed spaces create a warm, inviting atmosphere for both everyday living and entertaining. An impressive entry with custom wood staircase sets the tone as you enter this sunlight-filled home. The designer kitchen is a dream come true for any cook or entertainer while the adjoining dining room opens onto a spacious patio overlooking a private landscaped yard- an ideal setting for outdoor dining under the trees or viewing the abundant wildlife! Each of the bedrooms offers its own private bath and large walk-in closet. The primary suite provides direct patio access and luxurious bath featuring a tiled shower and soaking tub. A first-floor office enjoys peaceful pond views, while a convenient half bath and laundry room add everyday practicality. A large loft allows for flexible space for recreation or relaxation. The lower level expands the possibilities with a family room, bonus room, and full bath. An oversized garage completes the home's generous amenities. Don't miss this rare opportunity in one of the most stunning areas of Indiana. With virtually everything new, you'll enjoy peace of mind in this distinctive estate for years to come.

5941 S Poplar Grove Road, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Julie Timmons. Weichert, REALTORS®

$325,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Privacy, nature and 20 acres of opportunity! If you've been looking for a property where you can spread out and enjoy the peace and beauty of the outdoors, this wooded 20-acre parcel deserves a look. The mature woods provide a private setting with plenty of room to explore, enjoy wildlife and create your own outdoor retreat. Located on the property is a 3-bedroom, 1 bath mobile home featuring a comfortable living room and breakfast room, providing a place to call home while you enjoy all that the acreage has to offer. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend getaway, recreational property, hunting retreat or simply a place where you can enjoy the privacy that comes with owning acreage, this property offers tremendous possibilities. Imagine having your own 20 acres of woods to explore, with room for trails, recreation, gardening, hunting or simply getting away from it all. The changing seasons bring a different experience throughout the year, making this a property you'll enjoy in every season.

9089 Gold Point Road, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Molly Lawless. F.C. Tucker Company

$365,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

A horse lover's dream! Nestled on 15.15 scenic acres in the heart of Brown County, this exceptional 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom log cabin home combines modern amenities with the charm of country living. With a thoughtful layout and a range of features including a handicap accessible basement, heated bathroom floors, and a prime location just 10 minutes from Brown County State Park, this property offers both comfort and convenience in a serene, natural setting. Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat, a family home with room to grow, or a property that offers both comfort and accessibility, this home in Brown County provides it all. With its thoughtful features, ample acreage, horse barn, POND, and proximity to one of Indiana's most beautiful state parks, this is the perfect place to call home.

7021 Bellsville Pike, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Cassi Ostler. RE/MAX Edge

$399,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Now is your chance to own this rustic Brown County Log Home on 4.67 Acres! Discover the timeless charm and craftsmanship of this one-of-a-kind Brown County log home at 8035 N Dog Trot Ln. Custom built in 1998 using 150-year-old hand-hewn poplar logs, this distinctive home was handcrafted by a local artisan and showcases the character and warmth of a true Brown County retreat. Inside, you'll find beautiful custom white oak flooring, oak kitchen cabinetry, poplar walls and stairs, and authentic barn wood posts and beams that create a warm, inviting atmosphere throughout. The open-concept design features impressive 11-foot ceilings, allowing the natural beauty of the materials and spacious layout to take center stage. The home offers 2 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, making it an ideal full-time residence or a weekend getaway. Situated on 4.67 acres, the property offers plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors and the natural beauty of the surrounding area. Step outside and relax around the firepit area, perfect for evenings under the stars, entertaining guests, or simply enjoying the tranquility of your own Brown County escape. A rare opportunity to own a handcrafted log home filled with history, character, and local craftsmanship.

8035 N Dog Trot Lane, Morgantown

Listing courtesy of Hannah Harrell. Berkshire Hathaway Home

$424,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 7951 Laurel Drive, a newly constructed single-family residence built in 2025 with a RECENTLY COMPLETED 2-CAR GARAGE. This 1920 square foot home offers a unique opportunity to embrace modern living on a generous 3/4 acre lot, providing ample space for outdoor enjoyment and future possibilities. This charming home features three comfortable bedrooms, offering private retreats for all occupants. Two full bathrooms including a primary bedroom en suite plus one convenient half bathroom ensure comfort and functionality. The garage which has a vapor barrier and overhead fans could also be used as a flex space. The property includes access to all the wonderful amenities offered in the Cordry Sweetwater Conservancy District. Launch your boat at either lake, swim at the largest private beach in Indiana, challenge your family and friends to some friendly competition at the basketball and pickleball courts - the list just goes on! Discover the potential of this exceptional property and envision your future here.

7951 Laurel Drive, Nineveh

Listing courtesy of Nancy Lee. Sweetwater Realty LLC

$1,175,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths

Private 40+/- Acre Log Cabin Retreat with Multiple Outbuildings Discover the privacy and space of this exceptional 4-bedroom, 4.5-bath log cabin situated on approximately 40+/- acres of beautiful pasture and grassland at 300 Airway Lane. Surrounded by open land and peaceful countryside, this property offers a rare combination of comfortable living, recreational opportunities, and versatile acreage. The inviting main home features a warm and rustic interior highlighted by cathedral ceilings and a stunning Brown County stone wood-burning fireplace, creating the perfect gathering space for family and friends. With four bedrooms and four-and-a-half baths, there is plenty of room for everyday living or hosting guests. A guest quarters above the detached 3-car garage provides additional private living space, making it ideal for extended family, guests, a home office, or a private retreat. The property also offers an impressive collection of outbuildings, including 40x60 and 48x25 pole buildings, plus an additional 16x32 building. All feature concrete floors and electricity, providing abundant space for equipment, vehicles, hobbies, workshops, storage, or agricultural use. Enjoy the outdoors with approximately 40 acres of pasture and grassland, along with a stocked pond offering a peaceful setting and recreational potential. The expansive acreage provides room for a variety of uses while maintaining a wonderful sense of privacy. Modern conveniences include high-speed internet and natural gas, allowing you to enjoy the tranquility of a private rural setting without giving up important amenities. Whether you're looking for a private country estate, a hobby farm, recreational property, or a peaceful place to call home, this unique Brown County-area property offers space, privacy, character, and versatility that is hard to find.

300 Airway, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Danny Key. Brown County Real Estate

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

**Escape to Brown County** Set on 2.64 private acres in Brown County, Indiana, this one-of-a-kind home offers 4,074 square feet of thoughtfully rebuilt living space, custom finishes, and a rare mix of privacy, nature, and everyday convenience. Completely rebuilt in 2021, the residence is well insulated, very well maintained, and finished with materials that feel both grounded and distinctive. Pennsylvania hardwood floors, tile, and vinyl are used throughout in a tasteful mix. Local hardwoods continue into the family room, foyer, ceilings, and other living areas, giving the interior a warm, cohesive character that suits the wooded setting. A metal roof, abundant storage, and a dedicated bonus room add lasting practicality. The kitchen is designed for both daily comfort and entertaining, with granite countertops and a wood stove that becomes a natural gathering point. Expansive glass looks out over the pond behind the home, so the living spaces, and views stay connected to the water, trees, and quiet landscape beyond. The huge primary suite is a retreat of its own: a large sitting room, a full primary bath, two walk-in closets, and a separate room for washer and dryer. Two additional bedrooms and 2.5 baths complete the layout, with storage throughout that is unusually generous for the area. Outside, the property is framed by trees and a beautiful natural setting. A privacy fence along S.R. 45 screens the road while preserving easy access. Yellowwood State Forest adjoins on the west, which helps protect the setting and will hinder future building to the south and west. The pond, woods, forest edge, and acreage create the peace and tranquility Brown County is known for-yet you are not isolated from the region. S.R. 45 and S.R. 135 are close at hand, with workable commutes to Indianapolis, Bloomington, Columbus, and Martinsville. Homes of this scale, quality, and protected setting do not come to market often in Brown County. This is a unique property.

2981 State Road 45, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Paul Clark. Home Sleuth Realty, LLC

$289,900

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

This completely remodeled 24X36 garage was transformed into a stunning lakefront getaway in 2021. The former garage has been converted into a charming one-room efficiency with a bathroom, making it the perfect peaceful retreat on Sweetwater Lake. Enjoy deep water access with your own private boat dock, ideal for all your aquatic adventures. Spend cozy evenings around the large gravel fire pit or store your fishing gear and outdoor equipment in the spacious mini barn. An RV power hookup on the exterior adds convenience, allowing you to bring your RV or camper for enhanced outdoor experiences. Inside, the open vaulted ceilings and well-insulated spray foam construction create a cozy atmosphere. The kitchenette includes a refrigerator and microwave, while a washer and dryer offer added convenience. The large full bathroom features a walk-in shower, ensuring maximum comfort. A minisplit heat pump keeps the space cool for those times you want to unwind indoors. Surrounded by gorgeous mature trees, this property is a naturalist's paradise. Fully embrace the beauty of nature and the tranquility it brings. Check it out today!

6461 Quail Drive, Nineveh

Listing courtesy of P. Aaron Starr. F.C. Tucker Company

$639,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

RARE BROWN COUNTY RETREAT | 16.5 WOODED ACRES * 4-CAR ATTACHED GARAGE SPACE * ELEVATOR * WALLS OF WINDOWS! Privacy, space, and incredible wooded views come together at 6889 Foremans Passage. Tucked away on 16.5 beautiful acres, this upscale contemporary ranch offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, TWO attached 2-car garages for a total of 4-car garage space, and an ELEVATOR providing convenient access between both levels. Step inside to a dramatic great room with soaring 12-foot ceilings, bamboo flooring, a gas-log fireplace, and walls of windows that fill the home with natural light while showcasing the surrounding Brown County woods. The open layout flows into the dining area and spacious kitchen with abundant cabinetry and counter space. The main level features the primary suite, an additional bedroom, half bath, and the first attached 2-car garage. Downstairs, the expansive walkout lower level offers exceptional flexibility with a large family room, additional living area with built-in wet bar, spacious third bedroom, full bath, laundry room, utility room, mudroom, abundant storage, and the second attached 2-car garage. Additional features include new lower-level carpet, automatic blinds, tankless water heater, and a whole-house generator installed in 2024. Outside, enjoy fresh landscaping, a large deck overlooking the woods, flagstone patio, built-in firepit, peaceful surroundings, and frequent wildlife sightings. With 16.5 secluded acres, an elevator, walls of windows, TWO attached garages with parking for four vehicles, and easy access to both Columbus and Nashville, this distinctive Brown County property offers a combination of privacy, convenience, and space that's hard to find.

6889 Foremans Passage Road, Nashville

Listing courtesy of Ryan Ebener. 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate

$760,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

LAKEFRONT LIVING WITH A VIEW THAT IS HARD TO BEAT! Welcome to 7119 Drum Drive on beautiful Cordry Sweetwater Lake, where the setting and lifestyle truly take center stage. This property enjoys an exceptional position on the lake with sweeping water views that can be enjoyed from multiple levels of the home, expansive decks, the covered outdoor bar area, and the newer dock. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee, entertaining friends, or watching the sunset over the water, the lake is always the backdrop. The warm character of this home pairs perfectly with the relaxed lake lifestyle. The main living area features vaulted wood ceilings, abundant windows, and incredible views, creating a space that feels connected to the outdoors. The remodeled kitchen features custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a gas range. Additional updates include a remodeled bathroom, newer flooring, newer roof, and a newer dock. The outdoor spaces are designed for enjoying lake life. Multiple decks provide room to relax and entertain, while the covered outdoor bar creates an ideal gathering spot just steps from the water. The dock offers easy access for boating, fishing, swimming, or simply enjoying a chair at the water's edge. The detached garage offers much more than parking. Its walk-out lower level includes two finished rooms currently being used as a workshop and dedicated lake storage, providing valuable space for hobbies, equipment, water toys, and everything that comes with lake living. The sale also includes a substantial amount of the home's furniture, excluding the basement furniture, making this an easy opportunity to step into the lake lifestyle without starting from scratch. If you've been searching for a lake property where the view, water access, outdoor living, and overall setting are truly the experience, 7119 Drum Drive deserves a close look. Come see the view in person-you'll understand why this property is all about the lake!

7119 Drum Drive, Nineveh

Listing courtesy of Brian Hopson. F.C. Tucker Company

Advanced Search

Map Search

My Home Value

Your Brown County Real Estate Source

Newest Brown County Homes for Sale

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?